Of the islands many pocket communities, Lonelyville is one of the oldest on Fire Island.
Founded in 1905 by the South Shore Realty Company, this secluded town is characterized by its two distinct areas.
On the Western side, many original 1930’s cottages are nestled between the narrow wooden boardwalks, shaded by the lush vegetation.
Some vestiges of the buildings existing during the fishing operations of Capt. Selah Clock in the 1880’s can still be found.
On the Eastern side, homes sprouted up during the 1960’s along the more modern cement walkways. Though different in architecture, the two sides are joined by a love of privacy, relaxation, and comfortable lifestyle.
Many who reside here are long-timers, who have had homes here for generations. They share their town happily with the intrepid renters and newcomers.
There are no stores, restaurants, bars, or any of the usual amenities found in neighboring towns.
Groceries are brought from Fair Harbor or the mainland, and carried or wagonned in.
What is sacrificed in convenience is more than made up in the serenity and beauty of this special community.
Ferry service is from Bay Shore, use Dunewood ferry
