Beach Street Pizza & Grille and M&M's Ice Cream Parlor are located directly next to The Schooner Inn, offering fresh oven pizza and a variety of ice cream flavors.
Beaches & Cream is a small ice cream shop in Ocean Beach located right across from the ferry entrance.
Ice Castle Sweet Shoppe is the sweetest stop on Fire Island! Ice Castle has a large selection of delicious sweets including home made fudge, ice cream, Italian ice, iced coffee, specialty candies and more.
Rachel's Restaurant & Bakery was established in 1975 as a bakery and has since expanded the menu with full lunch and dinner fare. Come to taste the famous crumb cake, or try the fresh lunch and dinner options.
Scoops Ice Cream of Fire Island is locally famous ice cream shop serving Hershey's Ice Cream.
Sweet Licks of Cherry Grove is open from April-October. Sweet Licks serves a variety of Hershey Brand Ice Cream flavors, custom ordered cakes, pastries, shakes, cookie trays, coffee, and espresso.